Patreon vs Substack: Which Platform Is Right for You?

Do not index

Choosing between Patreon and Substack boils down to one practical question: how do you want to make money? The core difference is simple: Patreon is a flexible membership platform built for all creators—artists, podcasters, musicians—who offer a variety of content. In contrast, Substack is a dedicated publishing tool designed specifically for writers who are all-in on premium newsletters.

Defining Your Creator Strategy

Picking your platform isn't just a technical choice; it’s a strategic one that directly impacts your income. It's about matching your creative style with the right tool. This decision shapes how you deliver value, connect with your audience, and ultimately, make a living doing what you love. Are you building a close-knit community with a mix of exclusive content, or are you focused on establishing your authority through writing?

Think of Patreon as your digital fan club. It lets you set up multiple membership tiers, each with its own set of perks—like behind-the-scenes videos, early access to podcast episodes, or exclusive digital art. It's built for creators who produce more than just text and want to build lasting relationships with their most dedicated supporters.

Substack operates more like a premium magazine subscription. Its biggest advantage is its simplicity and laser focus on writing. The entire platform is designed to make publishing and monetizing a newsletter as easy as possible, helping writers connect directly with readers without getting bogged down by different content formats.

But what if you need to sell digital products alongside your content? Many creators realize they need a solution that does it all. For anyone who needs a newsletter, a link-in-bio page, and a storefront without piecing together different services, a platform like Pocketsflow offers a unified alternative. Start building your all-in-one creator hub on Pocketsflow today.

Patreon vs Substack vs Pocketsflow At a Glance

Seeing everything side-by-side is the fastest way to get a clear picture. This table breaks down the core features, ideal user, and fee structures of each platform to help you spot the right fit for your goals.

Category	Patreon	Substack	Pocketsflow
Best For	All creator types (artists, podcasters, video)	Writers, journalists, and thought leaders	All-in-one digital creators and entrepreneurs
Primary Model	Flexible multi-tier memberships	Paid newsletter subscriptions	Digital products, newsletters, and link-in-bio
Content Focus	Diverse media (video, audio, text, images)	Written content (newsletters, articles)	Newsletters and sellable digital products
Community Tools	Strong (Discord integration, polls, messaging)	Basic (comments, discussion threads)	Audience building via newsletters and lead magnets

After reviewing the key differences, you can better see which platform’s DNA aligns with your own creative vision. The best choice is the one that feels like a natural extension of what you already do.

Comparing Fees and Creator Earnings

Let's get straight to the point: how much money do you actually take home? When weighing Patreon against Substack, the fee structure is often the deciding factor. Your net earnings are what really count.

Patreon gives you options with its tiered pricing model. You can start on their Lite plan for a 5% platform fee, move to the popular Pro plan at 8%, or use the Premium plan at 12%. This flexibility is great for creators who want to start lean and add more powerful features as their community grows.

Substack, on the other hand, keeps it simple. They charge a flat 10% platform fee on every paid subscription. No tiers, no feature gates. This straightforward approach is a huge draw for writers who just want to publish and get paid without fussing over different plan levels.

The Hidden Costs: Payment Processing

Here’s the catch: neither the Patreon nor the Substack fee is the final number. Both platforms use Stripe to handle payments, which comes with its own transaction fees. Typically, you're looking at 2.9% + $0.30 per transaction for U.S. supporters, though this can shift for international payments.

So, your actual cost is the platform fee plus the payment processing fees. That little $0.30 per-transaction charge can really sting if you have hundreds of supporters making small monthly payments.

This is where the platforms start to diverge. This chart gives a quick visual on where each one shines, and how an all-in-one solution like Pocketsflow fits into the picture.

As you can see, Patreon is built for diverse content, Substack is king for newsletters, and Pocketsflow aims to be the central hub for your entire creator business.

A Real-World Earnings Example

Let's crunch the numbers. Imagine you earn 10.

Patreon (Pro Plan): You start with 80 (8%) fee. Then subtract Stripe's cut: 30 (100 supporters x 861.

Substack: You start with 100 (10%). Stripe's fees are the same: 30. You walk away with $841.

In this specific scenario, Patreon's Pro plan leaves you with more in your pocket. But change the number of supporters or the average pledge amount, and the math can easily flip.

Some deep dives into the fees show the race is even tighter. One analysis found that after all fees, Patreon's total cut came to around 12.7% (netting 1,000), while Substack's was 12.6% (netting $874). The margins are slim, but they become more important as you scale.

Payouts and International Considerations

Both Patreon and Substack pay you out through Stripe, giving you some control over your payout schedule directly from your Stripe dashboard. It’s a reliable system.

If you’re an international creator, however, keep an eye on currency conversion fees. When Stripe converts your earnings from USD to your local currency, it will take an additional percentage, which can eat into your profits.

If juggling different fee structures sounds exhausting, you're not alone. Creators who want to sell courses, digital products, and run a community from one place find that a tool like Pocketsflow simplifies things immensely. With one clear pricing model, you keep more of what you earn. Check out our strategic guide comparing different online course platforms to see how an all-in-one platform can fit your business.

Content, Delivery, and How You Make Money

How you get your work to your audience is everything. It's not just what you create, but how people access it and pay for it. This is where Patreon and Substack couldn't be more different, creating two distinct paths for earning a living.

Patreon is best understood as a flexible, all-in-one fan club. Think of it as your digital home base where you can offer a whole menu of different things. A podcaster might share bonus audio clips, an artist could post behind-the-scenes videos, and a musician might drop early-access tracks.

The heart of Patreon is its tiered membership system. You create different levels of support—say, 5, and $10 a month—and each tier unlocks a new set of perks. This lets you appeal to both casual followers and your most dedicated fans. To see how powerful this can be, check out these top subscription model examples and see how other creators structure their memberships.

Substack: The Writer's Platform

Substack is a finely tuned machine built for one thing: the written word. The entire experience is designed to publish and monetize newsletters. Its editor is clean and simple, putting your writing front and center.

Instead of flexible tiers, Substack offers a straightforward, all-or-nothing paid subscription. You set a monthly and annual price, and readers either pay for your premium posts or they don't. That simplicity immediately positions writers, journalists, and thinkers as premium publishers, turning their words directly into a business.

For anyone focused on writing, finding the easiest way to start blogging is a great first step, as the principles of building a readership apply no matter which platform you choose.

How This Plays Out in the Real World

Let's get practical. The type of content you make will almost certainly push you toward one platform.

Choose Patreon if you're a:

Podcaster: Offer ad-free streams on a basic tier, bonus episodes on another, and a monthly Q&A video call for your top supporters.

Visual Artist: Provide access to a private Discord for 7/month, and send out physical sticker packs for $15/month.

Musician: Share early access to new music for just 5/month, and a personalized thank-you video for a $25 one-time pledge.

You'll feel at home on Substack if you're a:

Journalist: Publish free weekly news roundups to build your email list, then put your deep-dive investigative pieces behind the paywall.

Industry Expert: Offer a free newsletter with general tips, while charging for your in-depth guides and market trend reports.

Fiction Writer: Serialize your next novel by delivering one chapter each week to paid subscribers, building both anticipation and a steady income stream.

So, the strategic trade-off is clear. Patreon gives you a sandbox for creative, multi-format monetization, but it demands more active management. Substack offers a direct way to sell your writing, but it's limiting if you create anything other than text.

But what if you need both? If you want to run a newsletter and sell other things like courses or e-books, you'll feel the constraints of choosing just one. If that sounds familiar, you need something more unified. You can sign up for Pocketsflow to manage your newsletter, digital products, and link-in-bio page all from a single dashboard.

Building and Engaging Your Community

A loyal community is your most valuable asset. When you line up Patreon and Substack, you see two completely different philosophies on how to build that audience. Your choice boils down to a simple question: do you want to foster deep, interactive engagement or cast a wide net for organic reach?

Patreon was built from the ground up to be a community hub. Think of it as a private clubhouse for your most dedicated supporters. Its entire feature set is designed to create a sense of exclusivity and a direct line of communication between you and your fans.

This focus on interaction gives you a powerful set of tools to build loyalty. You can run member-only polls to let your community steer your next project, use direct messages for personal chats, and host exclusive Q&A threads that make supporters feel seen and heard.

Patreon: The Home for Deep Engagement

The crown jewel of Patreon’s community toolkit is its native Discord integration. It’s incredibly slick. You can automatically grant paying members access to specific channels on a private Discord server, which creates a vibrant, real-time space for conversation.

Beyond Discord, Patreon’s tools are all about adding value through direct interaction:

Tier-Based Access: Create specific community spaces or offer unique benefits at different price points, which makes your top-tier patrons feel special.

Direct Communication: The ability to message members one-on-one fosters a personal connection that’s hard to replicate at scale on other platforms.

Interactive Posts: Features like polls and Q&As make your audience feel like they're part of your creative process, which does wonders for keeping them around.

If you want to take things to the next level, you can explore adding community gamification strategies to make your space even more dynamic.

Substack: The Engine for Organic Reach

Substack takes a different approach. It prioritizes discoverability and reach over walled-off community features. Its real strength is its network, where writers can tap into new audiences using tools designed for growth.

The core community features on Substack are much more public-facing:

Recommendations: You can recommend other Substack writers, and they can recommend you. This creates a powerful cross-promotion engine that helps you grow organically.

Guest Posts: Collaborating with other writers is a fantastic way to expose your work to a new base of subscribers.

Discussion Threads: While simpler than Patreon, the comment sections on Substack allow for public conversation around your articles, drawing in new readers.

This difference is also obvious in their analytics. Patreon provides a deeper dive, letting you track members, upgrades, downgrades, and income stats in real-time. Substack’s analytics are simpler, zeroing in on readership metrics but lacking the detailed user behavior data that can boost member retention.

Ultimately, if your business model involves selling high-value digital products directly to your community, you’ll need more than just engagement tools. To turn your audience into paying customers, check out our guide on how to create and sell digital products. For creators who need a powerful newsletter and a seamless way to sell products, a unified platform is the answer.

Platform Discoverability and Market Reach

Getting your work in front of new people is half the battle. Your platform choice plays a massive role in whether you can grow organically or if you're stuck bringing your entire audience with you. When it comes to Patreon vs. Substack, each offers a different path to getting discovered.

Patreon functions as a destination. Fans typically land on Patreon because they already know a creator from another platform—YouTube, Twitch, or a podcast.

This structure makes Patreon a perfect fit for creators who have already built an audience elsewhere. Your success there is directly tied to how well you can drive traffic from your main channels. It's less about being "discovered" on Patreon and more about giving the community you've already built a premium home.

Geographic Dominance and Niche Strengths

The data shows a clear divide in where each platform has the most influence. Patreon has a slight edge over Substack in overall popularity, especially in major global markets. Real-world usage data shows that Patreon is 1.4 times more popular than Substack based on the number of websites using each platform. In the United States, it’s the third most popular tool in the subscriptions category, with Substack right behind it. You can discover more insights about their comparative market share on WMTips.com.

This strong footing in the US, UK, and Germany makes Patreon a go-to for creators in entertainment, gaming, and the arts who are trying to reach a broad audience in those areas.

Substack, on the other hand, has cleverly carved out its own strongholds in different niches. It’s making serious headway in countries like Italy, Brazil, and India, and has become the definitive platform for writers specializing in business, news, and political commentary.

The Substack Network Effect

This is where Substack really shines. Unlike Patreon, it has invested heavily in creating an internal discovery network. Its most powerful feature is the recommendations engine, which lets writers cross-promote each other’s newsletters. When a reader subscribes to one publication, they’re often shown a list of similar newsletters.

This creates a powerful network effect. A single recommendation from a well-known writer can send a flood of new, highly engaged subscribers your way. This feature alone makes Substack incredibly attractive for writers starting with a smaller audience. For more ideas on picking the right platform, check out our guide on the best membership site platforms for your business.

In the end, neither platform is a magic wand for growth. Patreon gives you the tools to monetize an audience you already have, while Substack gives you a chance to be discovered by a new one.

If you’d rather control your audience growth without being locked into a single platform's ecosystem, a more centralized tool is the way to go. Sign up for Pocketsflow to build a powerful link-in-bio page and capture subscribers directly, giving you complete ownership of your audience.

The Final Verdict: When to Choose Each Platform

After digging into the fees, features, and philosophies, where do we land? The choice between Patreon and Substack boils down to strategic alignment. It's about picking the one that’s the right fit for your content, your audience, and what you’re trying to build.

Your decision should hinge on two things: what you primarily create and how you want to make money from it. Are you building a multifaceted fan club with different perks, or are you focused on establishing yourself as a premium publisher?

Choose Patreon for Community and Variety

If your creative work is visual, auditory, or highly interactive, Patreon is almost certainly your best bet. It’s the go-to platform for creators who want to build a genuine community hub with flexible membership tiers.

You should choose Patreon if you are a:

Podcaster or Video Creator: This is Patreon's bread and butter. Offering ad-free episodes, bonus content, behind-the-scenes footage, and early access is exactly what the platform was designed for.

Artist, Musician, or Illustrator: Your work is experiential. Patreon lets you share process videos, offer high-res downloads, release exclusive tracks, and even manage physical merchandise.

Community-Focused Creator: If your main goal is to foster deep engagement through a private Discord server, run member-only polls, and interact directly with your biggest fans, Patreon’s built-in tools are simply better.

Choose Substack for Writing and Authority

Substack was purpose-built for the written word. It’s fantastic at helping writers, journalists, and experts package their insights into a premium newsletter and build a reputation as a thought leader.

You will feel right at home on Substack if you are a:

Writer, Journalist, or Blogger: If your writing is the product, Substack’s simple publishing experience is hard to beat. It removes the friction between writing, publishing, and getting paid.

Industry Expert or Analyst: For anyone selling deep-dive analysis or expert commentary, Substack’s model immediately positions your work as a premium, subscription-worthy product.

Creator Focused on Discoverability: This is a big one. Substack’s recommendation network provides a real shot at organic growth that Patreon just doesn’t have. If you're a writer hoping to get discovered, this is a major advantage.

When You Need More Than Just One Thing

But what if you feel boxed in? Many creators today are multi-hyphenates. You might want to run a newsletter, sell digital products like e-books or templates, and build a central brand hub. This is where both Patreon and Substack show their limitations, often forcing you to tape multiple tools together.

For those creators, an all-in-one solution makes more sense. A platform like Pocketsflow is designed specifically for the creator who does a bit of everything. It combines a powerful newsletter platform, a digital product storefront, and a customizable link-in-bio page into one seamless dashboard. You can run your entire creative business from a single spot.

If you’re tired of juggling platforms and paying multiple fees, you don't have to settle. Sign up for Pocketsflow at app.pocketsflow.com and build your business on a platform designed to grow with you.

Answering Your Lingering Questions

When weighing Patreon against Substack, a few questions always pop up. Let's tackle them head-on with some practical advice.

Can I Use Both Patreon and Substack Together?

Absolutely, and many smart creators do. The trick is to give each platform a clear purpose so you aren't duplicating efforts or confusing followers.

A common strategy is to use a free Substack newsletter as the top of your marketing funnel to build a large email list. Then, you can invite your most dedicated readers over to your Patreon for exclusive content like behind-the-scenes videos, a private community, or direct access to you.

To make this work without a hitch, you need a central place to point everyone. A link-in-bio tool like the one included with Pocketsflow is perfect for this. It gives you a single, clean link where followers can easily find your newsletter, your membership, and any other products you sell.

Which Platform Is Better for a Beginner?

For anyone just starting out, Patreon is generally the more forgiving option. Its tiered structure lets you test the waters with low-cost tiers—think 3 a month. This is a fantastic way to validate your idea and build a community without the pressure of delivering a masterpiece right away.

Substack, on the other hand, puts the pressure on from day one. To convince someone to pay, you need to deliver consistently high-quality writing. While its network can help you get discovered, the simple paid/free model can be a tough sell when you’re still building trust.

Is It Hard to Move My Audience Between Platforms?

Moving your audience isn't impossible, but it’s challenging. Both platforms let you export your email lists, which is the easy part. The real challenge is convincing your supporters to follow you to a new home and—critically—re-enter their credit card details.

That friction will inevitably cause some people to drop off. To minimize this, you need a clear communication strategy explaining why you're moving and what's in it for them. It’s a big reason why choosing the right platform from the start can save you a massive headache down the road.

Feeling boxed in already? Instead of worrying about a future move, you can start on a platform designed to grow with you. Pocketsflow brings newsletters, digital products, and your link-in-bio all under one roof, so your business can expand without making your audience jump through hoops. Sign up to Pocketsflow and build everything on one solid foundation from day one.